Beyond the IPO: Why a Fintech’s True Worth is Forged in Emerging Markets
In the high-stakes world of financial technology, headlines are often dominated by staggering valuations, blockbuster IPOs, and the disruptive force of neobanks in established financial capitals like New York and London. We celebrate the unicorns, track their stock market performance with bated breath, and measure success in billions of dollars. But what if this is a dangerously narrow view? What if the true measure of a fintech’s success isn’t its ability to shave a few basis points off a trading fee, but its power to bring millions into the formal economy for the first time?
This is the provocative question raised by Carlos Marmolejo, CEO of Mexican fintech Finsus, in a compelling letter to the Financial Times. He argues that the ultimate crucible for any fintech is not the Nasdaq, but the bustling, underserved markets of countries like Mexico, India, and Nigeria. It’s a call to shift our focus from valuation to value creation, from disruption to inclusion. This isn’t just a matter of perspective; it’s a fundamental re-evaluation of what success in the modern economy should look like.
In this analysis, we will explore this powerful argument, dissecting why emerging markets are the real frontier for financial innovation and how investors, leaders, and the industry at large should recalibrate their scorecards for success.
The Valuation Mirage: When Numbers Don’t Tell the Whole Story
For the past decade, the fintech narrative has been one of explosive growth. Companies armed with sleek apps and disruptive business models challenged the dominance of traditional banking, promising a new era of democratized finance. The stock market responded with enthusiasm, showering these companies with capital and sending valuations into the stratosphere. However, the recent market correction has served as a harsh reality check. Many high-flying fintech stocks have tumbled, revealing the fragility of models built on user growth at any cost, rather than sustainable profitability and real-world utility.
The obsession with valuation creates a distorted incentive structure. It prioritizes capturing market share in developed, highly competitive economies where the primary “problem” being solved is often one of convenience for the already-banked. While valuable, this pales in comparison to the challenges faced elsewhere. The true test of financial technology is not simply creating a better user interface for an existing system, but building entirely new financial rails where none existed before.
This is where the focus on emerging markets becomes critical. These regions are not just another market to enter; they are the ultimate proving ground for a fintech’s technology, business model, and social impact.
The Real Frontier: Solving Foundational Problems in Emerging Economies
While a fintech in San Francisco might focus on optimizing investment portfolios, a fintech in Nairobi is focused on allowing a farmer to securely receive payment for the first time. The scale of the opportunity—and the problem—is immense. According to the World Bank’s Global Findex database, approximately 1.4 billion adults globally remain unbanked. They operate in a cash-only world, cut off from the tools of saving, credit, and insurance that are fundamental to economic mobility.
This is the void that innovative fintechs are filling, often by “leapfrogging” traditional infrastructure. Without the baggage of legacy banking systems, these companies can build mobile-first solutions from the ground up. Consider a few landmark examples:
- M-Pesa in Kenya: Launched in 2007, long before mobile payments were mainstream in the West, M-Pesa turned simple feature phones into digital wallets. It allowed millions to transfer money securely, pay bills, and access financial services, dramatically boosting Kenya’s economy and becoming a global case study in financial inclusion.
- UPI in India: The Unified Payments Interface (UPI) is a government-backed, real-time payment system that has revolutionized India’s digital economy. By creating an interoperable platform for banks and fintech apps, UPI has processed trillions of dollars in transactions, bringing street vendors and small businesses into the digital fold. Its success is so profound that other countries are now looking to replicate its model.
- PIX in Brazil: Similar to UPI, Brazil’s central bank launched the instant payment platform PIX in 2020. It quickly gained massive adoption, enabling free, 24/7 transfers for millions of Brazilians and significantly reducing the country’s reliance on cash and expensive traditional bank transfers.
These examples demonstrate that the most profound innovations in finance aren’t happening on Wall Street trading floors; they are happening on the streets of Mumbai and in the rural villages of Kenya. They are solving fundamental human needs, not just first-world problems.
A New Fintech Scorecard: Metrics That Truly Matter
If we accept that the traditional metrics are insufficient, how should we evaluate the success of a fintech, particularly one operating in an emerging market? We need a new scorecard that balances financial performance with tangible social and economic impact. This means looking beyond valuation and daily active users to measure the real-world change these platforms enable.
Here is a proposed comparison of traditional vs. impact-driven metrics:
| Traditional Metric | Impact-Driven Metric | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| Company Valuation | Financial Inclusion Rate | Measures the percentage of a target unbanked/underbanked population that the fintech has successfully brought into the formal financial system. |
| Revenue Per User (ARPU) | Economic Uplift Per User | Assesses the increase in a user’s economic activity, savings, or access to credit as a direct result of using the platform. |
| User Acquisition Cost (UAC) | Cost Reduction for End-User | Calculates how much the fintech saves its users compared to legacy alternatives (e.g., remittance fees, loan interest, transfer costs). |
| Stock Market Performance | Contribution to Local GDP | Evaluates the fintech’s broader economic footprint, including job creation and the formalization of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). |
By adopting a framework like this, investors and analysts can gain a more holistic understanding of a company’s health and long-term potential. A fintech that is steadily increasing the savings rate of its users and lowering the cost of credit is building a far more sustainable and defensible business than one that is simply burning cash to acquire users in a saturated market.
Beyond the Delay: The Hidden Financial Shockwaves of the Eurostar Disruption
From Local Solutions to Global Blueprints
A fascinating consequence of this shift in focus is that the innovations born out of necessity in emerging markets are now being exported globally. The constraints of these environments—low-bandwidth internet, lower-spec smartphones, and extreme price sensitivity—force developers to build hyper-efficient, simple, and robust technology. This “frugal innovation” often results in superior products that find applications everywhere.
QR code payments, for example, became ubiquitous in China and India long before they saw widespread adoption in the U.S. and Europe. The architecture behind real-time payment systems like UPI and PIX is now being studied by central banks around the world, including the U.S. Federal Reserve for its FedNow service. Even the application of technologies like blockchain finds its most compelling use case in solving problems like cross-border remittances, a lifeline for many families in emerging economies that is plagued by high fees from traditional banking incumbents.
Success in these markets is not just about local impact; it’s about creating the blueprint for the future of global finance. It proves that technology can create financial systems that are not only more efficient but also fundamentally more equitable.
Conclusion: Redefining the Future of Finance
The global economy stands at a crossroads. We can continue to measure success by the fleeting froth of the stock market and the valuations of companies serving the top of the pyramid, or we can embrace a more profound and sustainable definition. As Carlos Marmolejo rightly asserts, the true test for the financial technology industry lies in its ability to empower the powerless, to bank the unbanked, and to build inclusive economies from the ground up.
For investors, this is a call to look beyond the quarterly earnings report and assess the deep, long-term value being created. For business leaders, it is a challenge to orient their innovation toward solving the world’s most pressing financial challenges. And for all of us, it is a reminder that the most powerful force in the economy is not just the movement of capital, but the expansion of opportunity. The future of finance is not just digital; it’s inclusive. And it is being forged today, not in the towers of global finance, but in the hands of billions gaining access to the formal economy for the very first time.
