The Christmas Card Portfolio: Reimagining a Holiday Tradition for the Modern Investor

The Hidden Costs of Holiday Cheer

Each year, as the holidays approach, a familiar ritual begins. We draft lists, write heartfelt messages, and send festive cards to friends, family, and colleagues. It’s a tradition steeped in connection and goodwill. But have you ever paused to consider the true cost? It’s not just the price of the card and the stamp; it’s a recurring annual expenditure with a return on investment that is purely sentimental. In an era of increasing financial awareness and technological advancement, one has to wonder: is there a better way?

This very question was elegantly posed in a letter to the Financial Times by Peter Devlin. His proposal was simple yet revolutionary: instead of sending Christmas cards, invest the money you would have spent into a good equity fund. Then, a year later, send everyone on your list a statement of the fund’s performance. This idea, at first glance a quirky alternative to a cherished tradition, is in fact a profound entry point into a discussion about modern finance, the psychology of investing, and the transformative power of financial technology.

Let’s unpack this “Christmas Card Portfolio” concept and explore how a small shift in holiday habits could offer a powerful, year-round lesson in wealth creation, financial literacy, and the future of our digital economy.

The Compounding Power of a Simple Greeting

Before diving into the investment mechanics, it’s important to quantify what we’re working with. The greeting card industry is substantial. In the United States alone, consumers purchase approximately 6.5 billion greeting cards each year, with Christmas cards being the most popular category at 1.6 billion units (source: Greeting Card Association). If an average household sends 20 cards, at a conservative cost of $5 per card (including postage), that’s $100 per year dedicated to this tradition.

While $100 may not seem like a portfolio-defining sum, Devlin’s idea hinges on one of the most powerful forces in finance: compound interest. By redirecting that annual “card budget” into an investment vehicle like a low-cost S&P 500 index fund, you are not just saving $100; you are putting that money to work. The magic happens over time, as your returns begin to generate their own returns.

Consider the potential growth of this modest annual investment. The following table illustrates the hypothetical growth of a $100 annual “Christmas Card Fund,” assuming an average annual return of 8% from the stock market, a figure often used as a historical benchmark.

This simple act transforms a fleeting seasonal expense into a tangible, growing asset. The annual “performance statement” becomes more than just a novelty; it’s a real-world demonstration of long-term equity investing principles. It shifts the conversation from “Did you get my card?” to “Look at what our collective decision not to send cards has built.”

The Whale in the Portfolio: A 19th-Century Lesson on Stranded Assets and the Modern Energy Transition

Fintech: The Engine for a Modern Tradition

While Devlin’s idea is powerful in its simplicity, the rise of financial technology (fintech) makes its execution easier and more impactful than ever before. In the past, investing $100 would have been cumbersome, with high commission fees from traditional brokerage firms eating into any potential gains. Today, the landscape of banking and trading has been completely reshaped.

Micro-investing platforms have democratized access to the stock market. Apps allow users to invest with just a few dollars, buy fractional shares of expensive stocks, and set up automated recurring investments. These tools remove the friction that once kept small-scale investors on the sidelines. The “Christmas Card Fund” is no longer a complex undertaking but something that can be set up on a smartphone in minutes.

But we can take the technological application even further. Imagine leveraging blockchain to enhance this concept:

• Tokenization: Instead of a paper statement from a fund, you could airdrop a “Holiday Investment Token” to your recipients’ digital wallets each year. This token would represent their fractional ownership in the growing fund. It becomes a digital, tradable asset—a true gift that combines sentiment with utility.
• Transparency and Automation: A smart contract on a blockchain could govern the fund. It could automatically pull the $100 from your account each year, invest it in a predetermined asset, and distribute the performance data—or the tokens themselves—to a list of wallet addresses. This removes the manual effort and creates a perfectly transparent and immutable record, solving Devlin’s “who sent one to whom” problem permanently.
• Decentralized Finance (DeFi): The fund itself could exist within the DeFi ecosystem, potentially earning yield through staking or lending protocols, further enhancing the returns beyond standard market performance.

This evolution from a paper card to a paper statement to a digital token represents a microcosm of the entire evolution of finance. It’s a move toward greater accessibility, transparency, and individual empowerment, all driven by cutting-edge financial technology.

The Swedish Christmas Portfolio: Building Financial Resilience in a Volatile World

A National Lesson in Economic Empowerment

Zooming out, the implications of this mindset shift are enormous. A primary challenge facing the modern economy is a widespread lack of financial literacy. A 2022 study revealed that only 34% of adults in the U.S. could correctly answer at least four questions on a five-question financial literacy quiz (source: TIAA Institute-GFLEC Personal Finance Index). This knowledge gap creates barriers to wealth creation, retirement security, and economic mobility.

Initiatives like the “Christmas Card Fund” serve as powerful, practical educational tools. They make abstract economic concepts—like market growth, risk, and compounding—personal and tangible. Receiving a statement showing a real loss one year and a significant gain the next provides a more visceral lesson in market volatility and the importance of long-term perspective than any textbook could. It demystifies the world of investing and transforms it from an intimidating domain for experts into a relatable, annual conversation among loved ones.

If adopted on a larger scale, this collective redirection of capital could have a measurable economic impact. Billions of dollars currently spent on a single-use product could instead be funneled into the productive capital of the stock market, fueling business growth and innovation while simultaneously building household wealth.

Navigating the Risks: Investing is Not a Greeting Card Guarantee

Of course, it is crucial to approach this idea with a clear-eyed view of the risks. The stock market does not only go up. A key part of the financial lesson is understanding and enduring downturns. What happens when the annual “card” is a statement showing a 15% loss? This is where the educational component becomes most critical.

The conversation must be framed around long-term horizons. A single year’s performance is merely a snapshot in a multi-decade journey. This is a lesson in emotional discipline—the ability to stay the course during periods of volatility rather than panic-selling at the bottom. The sender of the “investment card” takes on the role of an educator, reminding recipients that downturns are a normal part of the economic cycle and often represent buying opportunities for the long-term investor.

The choice of investment also matters. A diversified, low-cost index fund is a far more prudent choice for this experiment than speculative single stocks or volatile cryptocurrencies. The goal is not to demonstrate high-risk trading but to illustrate the steady, patient process of wealth accumulation.

Flawed Models, Hidden Growth? Debunking the Brexit 'Doppelgänger' Narrative

Conclusion: A New Tradition for a New Era

Peter Devlin’s letter to the editor presents more than just a clever financial tip; it’s a challenge to re-examine our traditions through the lens of purpose and value. The “Christmas Card Portfolio” is a beautiful synthesis of old-world sentiment and new-world financial wisdom. It preserves the spirit of connection and giving but transforms it into a legacy of financial empowerment and education.

By replacing a simple piece of paper with a stake in our collective economic future, we offer a gift that truly keeps on giving. It’s a lesson in patience, a demonstration of compounding, and a conversation starter about the principles of building long-term wealth. In an increasingly complex financial world, perhaps the most valuable gift we can share is knowledge. And it can all start with a single, un-sent Christmas card.